The
Strad Magazine, London
November 1993
Masters
of the Sublime
By David Denton
Brahms:
Piano Quintet in F minor, Op. 34
Lev
Natochenny (piano)
Penderecki String Quartet
With
a catalogue that is not exactly short of Brahms Piano Quintets, is there
really a need for another one? The answer in this case is very much
in the affirmative. Rarely can the work's youthful exuberance have been
so perfectly captured in a performance that comes right from the heart
of these excellent musicians.
The
Penderecki Quartet was formed in 1981, and though they have toured extensively
throughout Europe and North America, this appears to be their recording
debut in this country. In all respects they are ideal for this quintet,
their big and bold tone bringing a weight and passion to the dramatic
moments, while the jagged Scherzo is full of excitement. They make a
great deal of dynamic markings, quiet passages being very pianissimo,
and at times you may feel the tone becomes a little rough in their effort
to build fortissimo passages - the leader digging in at the heel of
the bow in the Scherzo. Unanimity between quartet and pianist is not
beyond reproach, but one should not harp on such matters when the reading
has the adrenalin pumping through the body from the opening bar.
Lev
Natovhenny makes a fine partner, balancing himself expertly with the
strings, assertive at the appropriate moments and caressingly beautiful
in the quiet melodic passages.
Back
to Reviews