The
Record
Thursday January 28, 1999
Quartet,
pianist put on dream concert
By Colleen Johnston
The
Kitchener-Waterloo Chamber Music Society's Music Room was the place
to be on Wednesday.
Filled
to capacity, and buzzing with excitement, the venue hosted the Penderecki
String Quartet (PQ). Along with pianist Francine Kay, the PQ performed
what can be considered a dream program.
Ideal
for the listeners, at any rate. For the musicians (Jeremy Bell and Jerzy
Kaplanek, violins; Christine Vlajk, viola; Paul Pulford, cello; Kay)
tackling Schumann's Quintet in E-Flat, Op. 44 and following this with
Brahm's Quintet in F Minor, Op. 34 is a formidable undertaking, and
certainly not for the faint-hearted, as the PQ and Kay amply demonstrated.
In
short, the evening turned out to be among the finest of this musical
season. Both works were played with crackling energy in keeping with
the composers' intentions. Romantic to the hilt, Schumann's four-movement
Quintet demands impeccable ensemble blend.
A
kaleidoscope of skillfully written sections which explore the expressive
capabilities of the instrumentalists, Schumann's is a score to which
later chamber music composers, including Brahms, looked for inspiration.
Clearly,
audience members turned out to hear the PQ. This foursome has earned
a reputation of high acclaim over the past several years as artists-in-residence
at Wilfrid Laurier University's faculty of music. Devotees were especially
keen to hear Bell, in his first official performance with the PQ. Bell
studied at the University of Toronto and State University of New York
at Stonybrook, and replaces violinist Piotr Buczek.
Bell
was given the first violin part for the Schumann - a generous move on
the part of the PQ personnel. Among the many reasons the PQ has managed
to acquire their rich, unified sonority is that the so-called first
and second violins regularly change roles, a rarity among string quartets.
This gesture of trust and welcome was commendable, and while Bell's
sound was crisp, and at times clipped, phrasings were refreshing. It
will be interesting to see in future concerts how he adapts to the more
sweet, mellow sound of his partners.
Blend
and tuning were more happily wed when Bell was second violin in the
Brahms composition.
Like
Schumann, Brahms took commonplace musical fare (arpeggois, folksy melodic
snippets, majestic fanfare motives, dovetailing sighs, thunder chords)
and stretched the possibilities to the max. Yes, the boldness of the
work is a thrill in itself; with Kaplanek and Kay in charge, it was
spine tingling.
If
the element power of the lapel-grabbing sections was bracing, even more
satisfying for listeners was the tenderness, the caressing shyness,
of Brahm's second-movement Andante, un poco Adagio.
Hesitant
minor thirds built to a glorious harmonic exchange between the musicians,
culminating in a movement which stands out among 19th century works
as perhaps the most beautifully written, logical, intelligent aural
testaments to dignity and passion.
Violinist
Kaplanek was the perfect model for the quartet.
Kay,
in the both, performed to the level of divine. Patrons came to hear
the PQ, but they also resist Kay's leadership, focus, solid technical
prowess, and sure control of the entire scores, page by page. Kay and
the PQ, throughout personnel changes, always deliver.
And
let's not forget the sheer professionalism and marvellous contributions
of Vlajk (who is another fairly recent addition to the PQ and who fits
into the quartet like she was always a member), and Pulford, with his
plummy sound and superb combination of lightness and strength.
Back
to Reviews