Rhein-Neckar-Zeitung
August 11, 1994
Masters
of the Sublime
By Rainer Köhl
The
Penderecki String Quartet Plays in the Church of the Holy Spirit
Bach
is the alpha and omega of all music. In their appearance in Heidelberg's
Church of the Holy Spirit, the Penderecki String Quartet made arrestingly
clear how Bach shines even in the genre of string quartet: in the late
Beethoven quartets as well as in Shostakovitch. The Penderecki Quartet
was founded in Poland in 1981; it gives authoritative interpretations
of works of Krzysztof Penderecki, for whom it is named, as it does for
innumerable other quartets of this century. Under contract to a British
record company, the Penderecki Quartet has found its new home in Canada.
The
appearance in the Church of the Holy Spirit was originally planned for
the Bach Festival week. Hence this conclusive program, with Bach as
the starting point. Three counterpoints from his Kunst der Fuge were
rendered in an exceedingly exciting way. Contrapunctus I was done as
a quiet sotto voce song, as if from a great distance, drifting forward
out of distance in space and time, sublimely illuminated like music
of the renaissance, an interpretation that was directed completely inwardly.
So also Contrapunctus VI and Contrapunctus XI. The expression of this
music, with its tense chromaticism, was focused inwardly, turned toward
the intimate; the introspective character found a most lovely balance
to the high-arching motion in the direction of ever-arching expressivity.
At the same time, the interweaving of the lines had an elastic sound
with vivacious, dancing rhythm and sharply pointed dotted notes as well
as intensely glowing legatos.
Besides
the pronounced counterpoint, it is the expressive fourth-motif of the
opening, a dominating motto in the "stilo antico" that connects
Beethoven's a minor Quartet Op. 132 with Bach. The Penderecki Quartet
had the visionary gift of lending this opening motif a magically unreal
appearance, to let it shine forth as removed as if it came from another
world. The further course of the movement derived its form from this
refinement, dispensing completely with any forced passions, but rather
transforming seamlessly the tensely intensive into the sublime. There,
to be sure, it was not left there to disappear, but was granted a new
quality, so that it seemed to have been bathed in a different sphere.
The
members of the Penderecki Quartet are masters of the sublime. Jerzy
Kaplanek and Piotr Buczek (violin), Dov Scheindlin (viola), and Paul
Pulford (cello) offered an uncommonly refined sonority, splendidly rounded
in tone, extremely transparent in a homogeneous blend of sound. At the
same time, the playing is executed with constant attention to balance
in sound and playing.
It
makes a great impression that this young quartet did not try to fall
in place with the mainstream of Beethoven interpretation, and strived
for no conventional interpretation, but bravely and convincingly put
forward its own accent. This was no sentimental, overgrown playing,
but music-making derived from lyrical tension in seamless alternation
with wonderfully elastic relaxation. Surely this was the subtlest Beethoven
that one gets to hear from the most elevated classes of quartets, illuminated
with inner joy and splendid, mild sunshine. Wonderfully realized artifices
of sonic relaxation were to be heard, and divinely successful pianos
and pianissimos. A Beethoven for melting away, if it were not so serious
(and with this seriousness provided).
There
was splendidly matured sound in the slow movement, the introspective
character of the lydian mode sounded wonderfully sublimized, the bursts
of D-major grew out of it in revitalizing freshness and playfulness.
The expressively contrasting sections were not allowed to tear the movement
apart, but were rather brought into resemblance with each other and
conceived of as a unity grounded in sonic perfection. The fabulous first
violin Jerzy Kaplanek played with an extraordinarily refined lyric tone
and absolute security of intonation. The final movement came off delightfully
and completely without furious stretto-stress.
There
preceded the String Quartet Op. 110, No.8 by Shostakovitch. The long
double counterpoints of the opening Largo, modelled on Bach, were provided
with warm inner ardor; enormous verve, and musicianly involvement characterized
the Allegro molto, whose folkloric impetus was transposed into lightening
thundering attacks and whose pianissimo passages seemed to be changed
into the unheard, into etherial glimmering. Saturated in tenderness
and infinite quiet luster, as when the snow on a frosty but sunny winter
day achieves a quiet, mysterious magic. The quiet lament of the two
largo final movements acquired here not melancholy or depression but
rather tragic grandeur and a gently persistent intensity.
A
enchanted realm of quiet feeling and of subtle sonic values is opened
here, a garden of timbres ofthe most select colours.
Back
to Reviews